What was Dr. B.R. Ambedkar's reasoning behind burning the 'Manusmriti'?
This article is from a series of Questions asked on the internet and answered by Shekhar Bodhakar
Before I answer this question!, I would like to
point out the following:
1. Many supporters of the Manusmriti, commonly known as the Manuvadis, are
supposedly “answering” this question. THEY ARE NOT. They are
basically just leaving comments (not answering). They surprisingly received
many upvotes
2. On reading their answers, it is fascinating to note that NO MANUVADI HAS
ACTUALLY ANSWERED THIS QUESTION. (The WHY, the REASONING
behind the burning ). Instead, they have either praised the
Manusmriti or have condemned those who burn it. In their excitement (could be
on purpose too), they forget that the questioner simply wants to know the WHY
to an event that occurred on 25th December 1927.
It's great to include extra information to support
your answers, PROVIDED the question is actually answered . It does
not compute that someone volunteers to answer the question byAVOIDING to
answer the ACTUAL question asked !!
Here's my answer:
DR AMBEDKAR DID NOT BURN THE MANUSMRITI. IT WAS BURNT BY THE HANDS OF A
BRAHMIN NAMED GANGADHAR NEELKANTH SAHASRABUDDHE and Dr
Ambedkar, along with people of various castes including the Brahmins were
present at the event
Why did Dr. Ambedkar welcome the burning of the Manusmriti
Dr. Ambedkar based his philosophy on the belief
that the purpose/aim of human existence should be the cultivation of mind. No
person should attempt to prevent another person exercising this right.
i.e, in society there must be equality, liberty,
fraternity and justice to allow all to fulfill this purpose.
Dr. Ambedkar saw that the laws in the Manusmriti
were counter to establishing equality, liberty, fraternity and proper justice.
This cannot be achieved in a caste (Varna and jaati) based society. So the annihilation of caste (and anything that
supports the caste system) becomes an Ambedkarite’s priority number one.
I hope that answers the question asked
BBC NEWS (HINDI) Video exposes the Manusmriti:
The cruel punishments for violating the inhumane
laws of Manu were mainly directed towards women and the Shudras, depriving them
of the most basic human rights. Many extreme right-wing religious
fundamentalist are attempting the re introduction of the Manusmriti with the
aim of replacing the current Indian constitution with this anti humanity law
book.
WHY did the Brahmin, GANGADHAR NEELKANTH
SAHASRABUDDHE, put the Manusmriti to ashes ?
Answer: Because it contains hundreds (if not
thousands) of verses that encourage anti humanity behaviour, especially
towards women.
On 25th December 1927 at 9PM Dr
Ambedkar participated in the public burning of the Manusmriti at the hands of a
Brahmin, Bapusahib Sahastrabuddhe.
This has now become a public event known as
“Manusmriti Dahan Day” and “Istree Mukti Divas” or “(Indian) Women’s
Freedom Day” but is not highlighted by the Indian authorities.
SOME QUOTES FROM THE MANUSMRITI:
(11 & 12 are from other Brahmanic religious
texts that back the Manusmriti) :
1. If a person of lower caste adopts the occupation of
a higher caste, the king ought to deprive him of all his property and expel him
from his kingdom. (Manusmriti, X: 96)
2. If a Shudra (lowest caste member) dares to give
moral lessons to a Brahmin, the king is to get him punished by pouring hot oil
in his ear and mouth. (Manusmriti, VII: 272)
3. Similarly, if a Shudra occupies the same seat as a
Brahmin, he is to be punished by branding his waist (with hot rod) or getting
his buttocks cut! (Manusmriti, VIII: 281)
4. Even if the husband is morally degraded, engaged in
an affair with another woman and is devoid of knowledge and other qualities,
the wife must treat him like a god. (Manusmriti, V: 154)
5. Women should never be allowed by their guardians to
act independently (Manusmriti, IX: 2)
6. If a person of lower varna (& lower caste)
has sexual relations with a woman of higher varna, with or without her consent,
he is to be killed. (Manusmriti, VIII: 366)
7. If a Brahmin (highest Varna) abuses a Shudra
(lowest varna), he is to be fined mildly, but if a Shudra abuses a Brahmin, he
is to be killed. (Manusmriti, VIII: 267/268)
8. If a Brahmin kills a Shudra , he is to perform
penance by killing a cat, frog, owl or crow, etc. (Manusmriti, XI: 131)
9. Non-believers, including freethinkers, rationalists
and Buddhists, are not to be entertained respectfully as guests; though,
mercifully, they may be given food (Manusmriti, MS IV: 30)
10. The families of non-believers are destroyed sooner
than later. (Manusmriti, MS III: 65)
11. If a woman should not grant her man his desire, he
should bribe her. If she still does not grant him his desire, he should hit her
with a stick or with his hand, and overcome her, saying: 'With power, with
glory I take away your glory!' Thus she becomes inglorious. (Brihadaranyaka
Upanishad 6.4.7)
12. It is the highest duty of the woman to burn herself
after her husband. (Brahma Purana 80.75)
13. When a woman, proud of her relations [or abilities]
deceives her husband (with another man), then the king should [ensure that] she
be torn apart by dogs in place much frequented by people and the evil man
should be burnt in a bed of red-hot iron. (Manusmriti, MS VIII: 371/372)
14. Offering presents (to a woman), romping (with her),
touching her ornaments and dress, sitting with her on a bed, all these acts are
considered adulterous acts. (Manusmriti, MS VIII: 357)
There is more, a lot more ..
Also Read:
1. What were
Babasaheb Dr. Ambedkar’s five vows administered by him in 1927 on Manusmitri
Dahan Day?
2. Why should Hindu Identity be given up?
3. Why did Dr. B.R.
Ambedkar hate Hinduism?
4. THE REVOLUTIONARY 22 VOWS OF DR B.R. AMBEDKAR
0 Comments